by Jared Essig © December 23 2022, last modified.

17 Dec 2021, first published. 22 Dec 2022, Draft 2.2

A popular new holiday song is circulating which perfectly epitomizes the true spirit of X-Mass season. It informs us that “when love is gone, peace is gone, equality and tolerance are gone, along with honor and justice, which are also are gone, that IN OUR DARKEST HOUR hope lingers on.” Hope in what? The song declines to state, but obviously it is Santa Claus in whom we hope: this is naturally assumed. In other words, mom and dad. But given that we're all adults now, this means you, and me, and the GDP. Why lie about this? Lets just be honest. Our parents lied to us about Santa Claus, and now naturally most of us don't believe anything they have say about Mary and Joseph and their holy baby. And why should we? And why should love and peace, et al, return? Does anyone even know why did they depart in the first place, and why are they still gone? Well since truth is so far gone that no even notices its absence anymore, I suppose that honor and justice et al decided to depart with it. If you are a christian parent who holds that the advent of Jesus is the "reason for the season", then consider that [Hannukah](/hannukah_2021) is actually mentioned in the New Testament, unlike Christmas which is not. Jesus celebrated alot of Jewish festivals (which were later deprecated by the church, why?) but there is no record of him celebrating his birthday, nor is there any indication of his birth occuring in winter, let alone on Dec 25, or near the solstice. And if he did celebrate his birthday (and he probably did, but privately), it would have been accounted on the Hebrew calendar, which is lunisolar, and therefore would be a "movable feast" like the other Jewish holidays. Perhaps if you're honest about this, then you'll get more respect from your children when then grow up than most of my generation's parents are now getting from me and my peers. The church has given us every reason to abandon christianity, for it is obviously an apostasy. Returning to our discussion of the X-Mass holiday, if not the return of truth and every blessing therefrom proceeding? In practical fact, we and our supervisors are hoping that the holiday cheer will stimulate consumer spending, which will boost the aggregate GDP and therefore general welfare, in concert with whatever fiscal stimulus the government may have recently enacted in order to distract us from its general incompetence and to get itself re-elected. This is another form of "santa magic" that the government habitually performs, as our collective "mom and dad". Increasing demand will bring about higher prices or else increased production, which will lead to lower unemployment, or higher paychecks. In other words, we will collectively have less free time and more tchochkes, toys, and trinkets. Or else we will merely widen the current account deficit with China and other net producers of toys and trinkets. Thats basically what we're hoping in. ## The Emptiness of False Hope Somehow, I’m not greatly inspired to confidence or hope by the rather bland observation that hope lingers on, devoid of any plan, promise or strategy for restoring that which has been lost and is now gone. Perhaps the song was merely the second movement in a three part cantata, and I missed the prequel and sequel. For my own part, I’ve not lost love, peace, or justice thank God, so maybe this doesn’t apply to me. What has happened here? Perhaps it is my own obtusesness, but for the rest of you, what are you hoping in? And if you don’t know, then what do you do when truth is gone? Sing pretty tunes about meaningless vanity, with bright shiny faces, and wish for best? And why have such the bad attitude toward negative emotions? This song may be an example of what is now called "Toxic Positivity" ## Hate and Fear are not Always Bad, and Sometimes Good The song declares an intention to neither hate nor fear. But just like hope, no object is stated, so we are left to make assumptions. Certainly we shouldn't hate our neighbors and peers, but what about our enemies? Even Jesus who taught people to love their enemies, taught his followers to hate sin and and evil, insofar as they should abstain from it. Also, he was no friend to the corrupt government and religious leaders who had been installed by Rome. "Hate evil, learn to do good" Fear of vanities and illusions is bad, but the fear of death is innate, and it plays a natural role in helping us avoid danger. The fear of death can become pathological, and lead men to do all kinds of wicked things out of shear cowardice and passive compliance. That can be overcome, but not through scoffing at or ignoring the fear of death. The fear of the Eternal is the only way to overcome the fear of death. Therefore, once again, we should cultivate healthy fear. ## Remorse and Repentance are Preferable to False Hope Do you have any reason to believe that love, peace, and justice will return? Why did they leave in the first place? What did we do to make these virtues so unwelcome? What repentance must we do to restore this breach? Who do we call to invite them back?

Since the source and anchor of our hope is not stated in the song, and since truth is so far gone that its absence isn’t even missed, we are left with nothing but the societal defaults, which with all due respect to the elegant composition and pleasant vocalists, are quite hopeless. Given that santa claus doesn’t exist, that the envy, greed, and materialism engendered by capitalist consumerism create miserable dissatisfaction in the end, that lying to children exploits their naivete and causes them to rightly distrust their parents, that “magic” is fraudulent manipulation and deception, and that none of the gospels have Jesus born in winter nor later in life celebrating his own birthday, and that all of this is plainly obvious to any mature observer willing to seriously contemplate the obvious facts - what, I ask again, are we hoping in? (That was some truth, by the way - your missing ingredient) And if our midwinter holiday “hope” is a mere illusion, is false hope really is better than none? I tend to think not. I’d rather truthfully hope in nothing.

Reasonable Faith is a Sound Hope. Athiesm, Agnosticism, and Illusion are Not

And what hope can possible exist for an atheist or an ornery agnostic? If not from the obviously illusionary Santa Claus and the machine of post-christian capitalist liberal democracy that it supports, in its phase of the late post-decadent absurd, what can he hope in other than his next meal?

And if you are a christian who holds that the advent of Jesus is the "reason for the season", then consider that Hannukah is actually mentioned in the New Testament, unlike Christmas which is not. Hope in his return, if you believe he will return. And if not, that is all the more reason to abandon hope in the church and its futile pageantry. And have some shame about how you and your church have cooperated with your religion's corruption by commercial advertising.

And if you don’t hope in his return, then all the more reason to abandon hope in the church and its futile pageantry and instead use your time to study science and history.

Pleasure is Fleeting, Magic is Fraud, and Modern Man is Absurd

Beyond hope in sensual pleasure, honor, and wealth, (and perhaps "magic"), the athiest has nothing reliable to hope for except death. Because he does not beleive in his own spiritual nature, he does not cultivate it or invest in virtue. "There is no ghost in the machine", as a popular philosophy book says. Because he does not believe in an afterlife, he does not prepare for it. He does not believe in divine justice, so he has no motivation to do justice for others, or hope that seeking it for himself will succeed. So as a result he usually capitulates to systemic injustice rather than finding the moral courage to speak truth to power. Instead, he indulges his appetites and oppresses the poor and the stranger when this is convenient to him. Rather than choosing to feel guilt at his error, and shame over his corruption, he most often instead suppresses and denies his conscience, as if he were amputating a limb and branding the stump with a hot iron.

The vicious character of his soul causing him self-loathing from time to time when his awareness is suppressed by the entertainments wherewith he distracts himself, but self-loathing does not lead to authentic grief because, since he doesn't believe in his soul to begin with, there is nothing to lose. Instead of grief, shame, and remorse, he indulges shameless buffoonery with friends who feel the same way and consider themselves "sophisticated" for having arrived at this state. The irony holds behind it pseudo-intellectual mask of self-awareness and wit, nothing more than contempt - for himself and for the world.

Thus the post-war european philosophers say not only that "the condition of modern man is absurd", which is evidently true, but also unjustifiably infer that "life itself is absurd", which is not. This is the way of the tragic fool or the comic buffoon, not of the tragic hero, and it is merely they who are absurd. Life is not absurd; it is good. Art, literature, music, and modern so-called philosophy are absurd, yes. But nature is good, thank God, and so is life. The tendency to blame their own moral errors on the natural world, on genetic mutations, on God, or on the hypocrites who claim to represent him, or on life itself, is the moral great error of the athiests as they diligently pursue their absurd (but not quite tragic) folly into the depths of ignorance and despair, and then project it on the rest of us as something we are obliged to accept in the name of "science" or "progress".

Abandon Nostalgic Idealism

Next comes the nostalgic phase. Phony idealisms as an escape from cynical despair. Nostalgia for the hope and youth he lost. Back to the Academy and all its fascist elitism and neo-platonic gnosticism. Escape from reality. Or back to the theater, enjoying the experience of momentary transcendence afforded by music, art, or literature. The fleeting vision of the good life may awaken a desire for healing and return, and to become aware of this desire for transcendence is good. But the tendency in human society is to focus on the aesthetic as a way of avoiding the ethical questions that it raises. What matters to most people is not what the song says, whether or not it is true, or what the moral of the story may be; what matters is that it sounds good, feels good to sing together in harmony, and contains a vague reassurance that “everything is going to be ok”. And thats why we should stop hoping in art and literature to save us.

Sincere Cynicism or Ironic Despair

I prefer classic sincere cynicism to ironic despair, but both are better than idealistic delusion masquerading as virtue, and deceiving the young and simple with false promises and meaningless self-indulgent pleasures. Do you really want it to "linger on", or would it be better to let it go and give up?

Else Cultivate Authentic Fear

Face the fact that death may not be an escape for you. Stop listening to fools who despise knowledge and discipline. Give up your false hope in death. And accept the unknown possibility of what is even more terrible and dreadful than death itself: and life after death, and divine judgement. There is no escape from eternity, and you will reap what you sow. You may enjoy indulging mockery, but the last laugh is not yours, and God will not be mocked.

Let Wisdom Have Her Beginning

The fear of the Eternal is the beginning of wisdom.

But what are we hoping in: that he already came and now lives in the form of Santa Claus and hypocritical religious performance art?

Or are we hoping that he will return someday as he promised, to sit on the throne of his father David on mount Zion in the "city on hill which cannot be hidden": Jerusalem the Holy (Al-Quds), to judge between the nations with righteousness? If so, then Psalm 96-99 are the songs to sing. You can do this any time of year, since the day and hour of his appearance are not known. Orthodox Jews have the habit of singing this "new song" of messianic redemption every week on the eve of the holy seventh day. I dare say that this habit is preferable, and it certainly gives me more hope than what the churches, the shopping malls, and family parlor rooms have to offer.

Since the Advent of the Son of Man could come at any time, we should rectify our advent traditions. Also consider that the evergreen tree can be reminder that winter will end. This is hopeful sign, but if you chop it down and put it in your living room, it will die and no longer be ever green.

Tell your friends. Lets abandon false hope and vain traditions, find a more secure anchor for our souls.