by Jared Essig © March 17 2023, last modified.
This is a draft
truths Matter? Truth is important
Not all that is important is material. Metaphysics don't matter, because they're not material, but they are important, because there is an order and patern to the material facts of nature, discernible by the human intellect.
Dogmatically stated opinions should be approached with skepticism and acknowledgement, either of which can go wrong. (expand section)
There exist intentions in nature (purposes, goals, final causes, or teleology), and there is a meaning and purpose to human life, prior to and beyond merely "what we make of it." Knowledge consists of justifiable true belief. Evidence, logic, and reliable testimony are admissible justifications. Some truths are self-evident, and do not require proof. Intellectual and moral potential is what makes humans distinct from brute animals. People of all races and nations, despite their many differences, are equally human in these potentials. Their actualization in the cultivation of virtues such as temperance, courage, compassion, and justice, is "the good for mankind", and should be the goal of education and of human life. Moral statements can be true or false, and moral knowledge is possible.
Your life matters because human lives matter.
Having rejected these axioms of the traditional liberal arts, along with the Aristotelian corpus on whose system the scholastic university, in a tense compromise with catholic dogmatism, was founded, modern liberal philosophy following Locke and Hume denied the existence of final causes and purpose in nature, and the possibility of moral knowledge, as did progressive industrial scientism following Bacon. The meaning of life was reduced to "what we make of it". This academic denial of knowledge enabled the imperialism, colonialism, capitalist mercantilism, and racist massacres and enslavements that followed. Neo-platonic Academia and Roman religion are the wellspring of fascism and totalitarianism.
Instead of the language arts of logic and rhetoric, and then the analytic study of forensic, epeidictic, and political speech, biography, memoir, and history, our typical high school and collegiate "English" curriculum consists of literary fiction in constructing a collective mythography. A mass media industry has taught young people through cartoons, comic books, games, and sports entertainment that the meaning of life is to act out fantasies of power in fictional spaces, which are defined by magical thinking and facile dichotomies of "us" vs. "them", "good vs. evil", "light vs. darkness" in godless worlds of Manichaean martial dualism. This inherently alienating and unnatural cultural mythography teaches young people to seek gnostic self-realization through a hero's journey with will-to-power as the defining human drive and ultimate human "good." The distaste for mundane reality is projected backward into an avoidance of historical awareness, except where it suits a preferred narrative. The alienated gnosticism creates the conditions for both cultural fascism and cultural marxism, when young adults act out these media picarasques and seek to immanentize the eschaton through militant political revolution. This is the "live action role play" mentality, a privelege of the petite bourgeois wasp youth, but also a default habit of those who grew up with this media programming.
The contemporary "awakening" is a recognition that these epistemic and moral foundations of "enlightenment" modernity are both racist and dangerously hollow, and they are. But the marxist, islamist, and roman catholic responses all draw on the same cultural condition of alienated gnosticsm and will-to-power in universalizing missions of world domination. This is an error. Rather than looking to Marx, Mohammed, or Madonna for a dogmatic alternative, I urge that we read Aristotle's curriculum, with the attention that it deserves, informed by the elaborations, proofs, and corrections of Newtonian natural philosophy. The cognate systems from other cultures, for example the Hebrew Ecclesiast and Patanjali's yoga should be examined as foundational within the scholastic project, rather than relegated to "minority studies", "Asian philosophy", or "Old testament". Science is not merely "western" or "modern", nor is it the only way to attain true beliefs and give an account of them. It would be the first time in 2,000 years for this to happen. Ecumenical Aristotelianism, instead of marxism or neo-liberalism, should be the basis for civic education, the liberal arts, and movements for social change.
See also: Do Justice, Make Peace — 2020 Portland uprising
Teach self-defense, social dance, and applied arts
See also: Pledge: Health, Reason, and Virtue. Renounce: drunkenness, hazing, and misogyny
School physical education should teach youth non-violent boundary setting, social dance, and basic self-defense, prior to and above the meaningless competition and ritualized violence of sports, ball games, and performance art. This should complement the language arts curriculum of rhetoric and argument analysis. In my high school, the boys exhausted themselves for hours and hours every day, practicing for thursday or friday night, when they had the opportunity t fight another school's for temporary possesion of a ball, while the girls stood on the sidelines in miniskirts chanting "fight! fight! fight!" Actual "fighting" and "community defense" if you can call it that, were outsourced to a military and a police department consisting mostly of the lower classes, although this had more to do with harrassing poor people and other undesirables into leaving town so as not to disrupt the property values. None of us male athletes knew how to lead social or partner dances, because we had wasted all our effort learning how to fight each other over balls of various shapes and sizes, for no apparent reason except to avoid useful work, pretend to be busy, mitigate the extremism of gladitorial bloodsport, and pwin scholarships to higher institutions for these communal purposes, while entertaining the homoerotic speculations of adult viewers.
The dramatic thespians, at their best, acted out british christianic propaganda under the name of a mercenary producer of the renaissance entertainment industry, who obviously took most of the best lines and monologues from a woman. At its best, sinners were punished, lovers were married, and no one died. And we are left to assume that this is the good for mankind, and is therefore the meaning of life. But on average, like the literature department, theater consisted of vainglory, strife, and morbid obsessions with murder, suicide, and madness - despairing explorations of human error, and re-enactments of the absurd. Catharsis was seldom found. There was no purpose to life, except perhaps marriage. Although of this institution we were dogmatically skeptical, Shakespeare notwithstanding. There was no chorus in the theater, no rythym with the poetry.
The choir performed concerts for aesthetic purposes, they didn't lead audiences in responding to the tragedy. The dance team wore leotards and performed pantomimes of who-knows-what for assemblies and half-time shows, while everyone else sat still and silent, and gazed intently at their long legs and firm hindquarters.
The brass band marched and played for football games, but was silent for school dances. During the dances, we were all subjected tothe idiot winds of pop radio, whose lyric poetry our literature department had not taught us to analyze or deconstruct. Neither the band nor the choir was of any assistance in helping us recreate this or any other music: we were at the mercy of the DJs, the lying poets, and the typically misogynistic and ignorant "rock stars" who do more work than the literature department anyway at defining cultural values and teaching youth the purpose of life.
The mostly female dance team were of no help either in our social life, because they had only learned how to perform for the viewing pleasure of an audience. None of them could circle dance, square dance, or call a dance.
This competitive performance art is the utterly retarded absurdity that has been defined as advanced culture. By the way, my public high school was one of the best in the state in almost every field and category. I'm almost ashamed that I got such good grades, excelled in the extra-curriculars, and even enjoyed the experience.
Sadly, the conspicuous leisure, ritual violence, and general lack of creativity or useful work, more or less repeated itself when I went to an "private, elite liberal arts college", except this time it was significantly more expensive, there was lots of beer, and no chearleaders. The young women were ahead of us guys in discerning the error of our thinking, because in college we had feminists instead of cheerleaders, but they were mostly stuck in interdisciplinary departments where their critiques could be more or less ignored.
Instead of this unsatisfying mutual entertainment which impoverishes the lower and middle classes, we should teach and value creative work, the manual and applied arts/techne. Technology should be taught, along with math. Engineering with science. Instead we've de-valued them as merely "vocational education" not for "college track" students, while valuing the "fine arts" which which enable the cconspicuous leisure of the upper classes and their cult of meaninglessness and self-indulgence. The cultural value placed on sports and fiction by our neo-Platonic "Academic" school systems is a feature of graeco-roman leisure class white supremacy: it deliberately obfuscates truth and justice in order reinforce its social power.
Schooling must be reimagined (and re-discovered), along with community safety.
Teach Logic, Rhetoric, Ethics, and Law
The language arts curriculum should teach the classic liberal arts of logic and rhetoric (including verbal self-defense). Furthermore, they should teach argument analysis, worldview analysis, non-dogmatic ethics and law, prior to and above teaching the novels, drama, and poetic fiction which usurps all our time, often serves as a means for avoiding ethical reflection, does little other than prepare students for a lifetime of "cultured" media consumption. Our modern myths and epic poems and novels misrepresent the world: the poets lie today, just as they did when Plato and Aristotle made this same observation. Students can read novels in their leisure time, if they choose to, and should be taught how to psychically defend themselves from a mass media industry whose goal is not to educate or instruct, but to fascinate, amaze, and addict. Students need to learn how to use language performatively in every day life - what used to be called "etiquette" or "manners". How for example to ask a question, issue an invitation, make a romantic or sexual advance, decline someone else's advance, how to say "no" firmly and how to receive it as an answer, to make a request, propose a resolution or a joint action, to make a demand, to de-escalate conflict, how to make an appeal based on reason, right, and higher law.
Teach History, Justice, and Citizenship
see also: Bibliography & Curriculum § Post-apocalyptic philosophy
Back to school: Once students learn the traditional liberal arts of grammar, logic, and rhetoric (and composition), they should taught to read and analyze biography, memoir, and the manifestos, constitutions, and declarations that are the primary source material of history. They should learn analytic, epeidictic, forensic, and political speech, prose, and essays. They should learn to listen, remember, recite, persuade, refute, debate, propose, negotiate, compromise, and acknowledge the truth. Although I got A's in honors and AP English, these language arts and skills neither taught nor valued. I was raised on a diet of almost pure fiction and wasted my talent analyzing "literary fiction" rather than biography, history, or empirical reality. The only political science or ethics I was given in high school was the cynical violence of Machiavelli. Critical Race Theory has exposed the white supremacy inherent in the "modern" pedogogical system. Though we should start with common sense and the narratives of lived experience, we must find a firmer basis in order to sustain the critique of liberalism. Fortunately, there is one. Aristotle has been systematically ignored and deprecated by post-renaissance modern philosophers who never even read his works, despite that the scientific revolution came about in the scholastic "Aristotelian" university. Despite going to a ''prestigious'' liberal arts college, I never actually learned "critical thinking" nor the "liberal arts" until age 35 when a religious Jewish man introduced me to Maimonides. Despite majoring in "philosophy", I never heard a single lecture in real (Aristotelian) philosophy, just the existential ramblings of western imperialist ideologues intent on maintaining a status quo of tendentious ignorance and denial of the moral order. I got A's and B's.
Teach Analytics, Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math
In that order of priority. I call it ASTEM.
(expand section)
Deflation of our grades and credentials is deserved, necessary, and inevitable
Its time to unravel the conspiracy of mutual grade inflation that has enabled and reinforced white supremacy (graeco-roman imperialism) by teaching "culture" while denying the moral order, denying the meaning of life, and denying human nature. The reason the academics hate Aristotle is because they insist on maintaining these denials in order to avoid accountability and the inevitable deflation in the value of their credentials. But this dogmatic agnosticism can no longer be maintained. The condition of modern man is absurd. Although they cannot deny this, the mavens of the "culture industries" have responded by rebranding absurdity and despair into aesthetic values to be experienced for their own sake, and exploited for the sake of selling product. Similar to the existential role played by tragedy in ancient Athens, but without the catharsis. And post-modern youth exhaust themselves in meaningless hermeneutics and the exploration of sexual perversions and other human error, and occassionally try to escape into some failed 19th century idealism, recapitulating modern errors rather than correcting them. This is not adequate. Absurdity prolongs suffering, whereas catharsis will end it.
This is why I spent three years sleeping on the sidewalks under cardboard boxes and wandering the streets of Los Angeles talking to imaginary friends: it may have seemed "insane" to some people, but doing this was considerably less useless and immoral than doing data science for the tech-advertising industry, or getting a Ph.D to teach the "humanities" in academia, or practicing medicine under the dominion of the psycho-pharmaceutical industrial complex, or becoming a screen writer, movie star, or popular musician in order to perpetrate more fictions and useless innovations on an already oversaturated public.
Acknowledge the truth - Might DOES NOT make right. There is one species - the human species, and we are fundamentally different than brute animals by our rational and moral abilities. Our purpose as the natural rulers over the animal and vegetable kingdoms is not to exploit and consume, but to cultivate the earth and do justice, which is deeply rooted in our nature as social beings. White supremacy is over. And it was never very good to begin with. The sooner we can admit this, the sooner we white folks can accept the (rather minor) humiliations that we now suffer as partial atonement for our sins, the sooner we undertake remorse, repentance, confession, and the making of ammends, then the sooner the wars will stop and the healing will begin.
Idealism and Cultural Fascism
basic error occurring in Plato, latent in Catholic neo-platonism and Cartesian Rationalism, Kant, Hegel, German Idealism, most neopagan ideologies, nazism, as well as the Jung/Campbell style of storytelling popularized by Hollywood as heroic journeys, fantasy mythographies. The problem manifests of this in comic books, video games, sports entertainment. A basic cognitive error into which young people are entrained. It is compounded ad nauseum, most people grow up with it. The historic materialism of Marx and his followers was a rejection of this error, one that created its own problems.
Critical Race Theory?
J.Rossi and B.Weiss refuse to stand by while their students are indoctrinated, but fail to deal with problem underlying the auto-immune disease of CRT dogmatism, which was dogmatic ignorance. Richard Samuelson answeres the question How Should Slavery, Jim Crow & Racism Be Taught in Schools? by appeal to the declaration of independence as the "final cause" in American politics, noting Frederick Douglass's embrace of this, and his rejection of William Lloyd Garrison's anti-constitution abolitionism, and comparing CRT dogmatism to the latter. These abolitionist approaches agree with the Confederacy that the constitution is inherently racist. I agree with Douglass that its not, but it has been used that way. I agree with Samuelson that the history, including the history of racism, must be taught first, prior to teaching political, racial, or anti-anything ideologies. But Samuelson does not address the problem of anti-Indigenous and Anti-Jewish hate, both of which are implicit in Douglass's ideological preceptors among America's second "Great Awakening." Also fails to note that the teleology of the declaration is not inevitable or yet fully realized. CRT is sociological analysis for college level, after students have the analytic tools and knowledge of historic facts, and should be taught non-dogmatically, along with class and economic analysis, comparative religion and ideology, and other critical theory. As I have done here. Teaching it as ideology rather than as analysis is a basic error. Insisting on race-first analysis is as basic an error as insisting on class-first analysis. Either or neither might be appropriate in different contexts.
Material and Ideological Conditions of Ethnic Existence
Materialist analysis is necessary but not sufficient for understanding ethics and history. like ideological analysis. Both the idealism of Hegel and the materialism of Marx commit the same error of ignoring the other due to its errors, while insisting that their own approach is sufficient.
Historic Materialism aka Cultural Marxism
Both race and class analysis can be problematic when the are approached from a dogmatically materialist POV. (expand section)