by Jared Essig © December 25 2022, last modified.

17 Dec 2021, first published. 23 Dec 2022, Draft 2.2

Hannukiah

The Hannukah festival commemorates the rededication of the temple in 164 B.C.E by the sons of Mattiyahu the priest, called the "Maccabees", after defeating the armies of Antiochus Epiphanies and recapturing Jerusalem from their Seleucid Greek empire.

What is the meaning and significance of the hannukah to us who are heirs of Greece, we European and American offspring of Rome and Athens? And what should we do about it? For the conclusion in a nutshell, see below.

The Glory that was Greece

The Greek empire supposedly brought the "light of civilization" to the barbarians by setting up temples housing statues of gods that were in the form of men rather than animals, and by thereafter constructing Gymnasiums and practicing naked wrestling, homoeroticism, and general aggression. Via the Olympics, and via Rome, of whom our sports-entertainment complex are the proud heirs, the Greek tradition continues today.

They managed to co-opt and assimilate Egyptian and Syrian polytheism to their own while still remain politically and culturally dominant, and they did. But they could not assimilate Jewish monotheism, which is based on metaphysical, ontological and ethical premises which are fundamentally inconsistent with those of polytheism and idolatry, rejecting it a priori as the first and second commands of the decalogue.

Is Composed of Vanity and Lies

But what happens if you, as an artistically cultured Greek despot, encounter a "barbarian nation" who doesn't like your artwork, and furthermore claims to present an alternate "light to the nations?" And what if its light exposes glaring moral and intellectual inconsistencies and perversions in your own? What if your epic poets where revealed to be liars, and your priests imposters? What if the gods and goddesses they invent were exposed to be the illusions and the vanities that they are? What if your own philosophers, (such as Plato, Aristotle) were to more-or-less confirm this?

And what if, despite the smallness and weakness of this "kingdom of priests", as they claim to be, they were, in a way more enlightened and civilized than you? What if the helots and metics and komos and demes that you've oppressed for so long were to perceive the beauty of their holiness and desire to convert assimilate to that? Instead of to the glorious splendor offered by olympian zeus, or athena and apollo and the others? You might have a revolution on your hands.

Paul's Cultural Revolution

This cultural revolution was immanently possible for centuries before the apostle Paul brought it about. Now the greeks are no longer weaving garlands for Demeter or singing Paeans to Athena, are repitiously and compulsively kissing icons of a Jewish lady named Miriam, and calling her "mother of god". I don't entirely endorse this; but it is a historically interesting coda to the Hannukah story, a partial vindication of the Maccabees, and probably a moral improvement.

Christianity, however, largely adopted Graeco-Roman political culture and thats why Greece and Rome adopted it. In the war against the Maccabees, the Hellenizers still have the upper hand via the orthodox catholic church. Although they have achieved this cultural supremcy through worship of a Jewish god and his Jewish mother, that doesn't prevent them from rabid hatred of the Jewish people (consider the genocidal rants of their chief patriarch and preceptor John "Chrysostom")

Greco-Roman Imperialism and Clerical Privelege

Clerical privelege in regious centers all over the world is threatened by the mere rumor of a "kingdom of priests, a holy nation". Our imperial ambitions are supported by a political theology that relies on a clerical class to teach and enforce it through ritual and sacrament.

The coercive nature of greek assimilation is not through racist anti-semitism, but throughreligious Jew-hatred: pagan greek culture makes homoeroticism and fornication practically unavoidable, through imagining god in the image of a man and demanding worship, by elevating physical prowess and civic honor above moral or intellectual virtue, through denying him freedom of conscience to the philosophers of nature, through implied verbal violence, and actual violence carried out vicariously by institutions of civil society, against dissenting voices who are pathologized and marginalized, if not actually criminalized, which they often were. Aristotle was justified in leaving Athens; for Athens was corrupt as is the Academic Republic of today.

Therefore liberal democracy is not much better.

Attempted Spiritual Assasination

My parents have two close Jewish friends: one is married to a Roman Catholic, and the other to an Evanglical. For thirty years we have socialized, celebrating Christmas, Easter, and Thanksgiving, yet not once did my parents or their spouses show the slightest interestin learning about Passover or Hannukah, for example. Not even from an irreligous or merely cultural perspective. Like the Greeks who want to share their art and music with Jews, My parents paradoxically hate their Jewish friends with love. They hold the basic assumption, that Jews are irrelevant, inferior, have no further reason to exist as a distinct ethnic group.

One friend was raised without any connection to Judaism by secular Jewish parents who had escaped the Holocaust. Neither his spouse nor my parents bothered with any critical thinking about the conditions of coercion by "German christian" and Nazi ideologies, that had led to those secular parents abandoning their Jewish way of life. Thus my parents and the whole group have basically co-operated passively with Nazi plan to erase Jewish identity.

The personal history recounted here, [why I am not a Christian]() begins to recount my side of this story.

My own "family and friends" repeatedly tried to spiritually and morally assasinate me through ideological materialist fundamentalism and its opposite - christian dominionism, both in alliance for moral idiocy and historical denialism, and empowered by coercive hospitalization and medication. Their own son and brother and companion, whom they claim to love. And you know this quite well, what you have done. I could enumerate they ways, and I will, another time, because I won't forget. And never again.

Even though I'm not "racially" Jewish, merely a post-colonial outlander who couldn't and wouldn't assimilate to American christian dominionism and progressive modernity, and who wanted to elevate my soul beyond the vanity that I've been forced to consume. How could this have happened? Its not merely your own family dysfunctions - you've been programmed to do it. This is the coercive way that Greek tried to assimilate the Jews: dogmatically assuming their own superiority and then expecting to "help" others to making them imitate that.

Wasting my time on fictions, mythology and games Pathologizing dissent as mental illness, any rejecting as crazy any sound interpretation of Hebrew prophecy, or belief in God outside your religions of Christianity and Epicurean materialism. Scoffing and mocking at my complaints about church, commerce, and society, and family life Seducing me with food, drink, and games, and entertainment to distract me Denial of the moral order through presumption on grace, nihilism, or social privelege Abdicating judgement and moral responsibility Plying me with drugs and worse, the pseudo-science of psychiatric materialist fundamentalism Threat of police action for mere dissent and non-compliance, lack of access to the justice system except as a criminal defendent

Insistng that I forgive and forget Ignoring my entreaties for help toxic positivity, pathologizing natural grief and anger compartmentalization of the tragic into mere spectacle to entertain you, seeking catharsis that is merely vicarious, while denying me the catharsis which I so desparately needed and eventual found in defiance of you. Showing "love" in the form of material goods while denying moral support, with which I was expected to be content and give thanks.

I am discontent with that, and no thanks.
Its a miracle that I escaped assimilation and moral and intellectual death, since actual physical death or institutionalization where the only other trails open. Until I blazed a new one, that is actually a very old one, thank God.

Once again, my "friends and family" didn't do this out of some localized family dysfunction, this coercive superiority complex is a culture-bound condition of the Greeks and derivative societies like modern America, and they were programmed to do it.

For bringing me into the world, thanks mom and dad. But I will not be celebrating "Christmas" with you this year.

In a Nutshell

Stop forcibly assimilating Jews, it impoverishes us as well as them, and it doesn't work. Give thanks for the miracles (al ha nissim) of their victory against all odds over the Seleucid Greeks and other kingdoms and nations that have conspired to wipe them off the map.

Also have some remorse for our tradition of having cooperated with Greeks in this attempt at spiritual, moral, and intellectual genocide: for the so many years of "Christmas" parties and "Easter" dinners and "Thanksgiving" family gatherings with Jewish friends, (30, in my case) without a single commemoration of a Hannukah or of Seventh Day as a memorial of creation and Jewish sabbath.

Consider the light of the hannukah candle, and subject your own "Light of Reason" to some analysis under the "Light of the Law", and if you can't find better reasons of the things you do, stop doing them, and start doing better things.

Come Out of Her, My People

As saith John the Revelator of harlot Babylon, "Come out of her, my people, lest you be defiled by her sins".

Reconsider the vanity of Santa claus religion of materialist consumerism, and the idolatry of Santa Claus, and stop lying to yourself and to children. That is part of the reason why I am not a Christian: If my parents and teachers will lie to me about Santa Claus, then why should I believe anything they say about Mary and Joseph and their holy son?

If you lie to me about the date of Jesus's birth, why should I believe anything you say about his life, death, and alleged resurrection?

To rectify the Roman Mithraic day of "Sol Invictus", say the birqat kriyat shema, the morning blessing before reciting of shema, in which we give thanks to God for giving light to the world. After, you may say a prayer for Christ's second coming, if you believe it will happen. Then, do it every day as the Jews also do, approximately.

To rectify the Germanic Yuletide oak-ash fertility mysticism and its cult of war and human sacrifice, (which indeed was discontinued for good reason) then gather instead among a grove of trees that point to the heavens and are "ever green", reminding you that winter will end. Let the evergreen tree stand in its its grove of family and friends. Instead of killing a tree, read Psalm 1 and become like it, by returning to the Eternal, blessed be he, and to his holy law.

Primary Sources for Further Reading

{{expand}}

I added links to the Hannukah wikipedia article, to the primary source texts: 1 Maccabees, 2 Maccabees, Josephus's Antiquities of the Jews, Talmud tractate Shabbos