by Jared Essig © January 24 2023, last modified.

This Open Letter is granted to the Public Domain — print, sign, and deliver to whomever you wish.

17 Dec 2021, first published 23 Dec 2022, Draft 2.2 2.3 jaredscribe.com/evergreen-tree

Attention Fellow Humans. And Teachers, Presbyters, Deacons, Pastors, Bishops, Evangelists, and Members of the ____ church:

A Cut-down Tree Ceases to be Ever-green

Why cut down the trees to place them in christian churches and homes with lights, and presents during this midwinter season? The symbolic value of the the evergreen is destroyed when the tree is cut off from its source of life: As soon as you kill the tree, it ceases to be ever-green. When the tree ceases to be evergreen, it becomes merely a symbol of our confusion, hubris, magical thinking, and idolatrous cult of "Santa Claus".

The christians I've asked all hold it to be an element from German paganism that has been appropriated as a Christmas symbol of new life in Christ. It has become that, but originally it was a montheistic anti-pagan symbol. The evergreen tree in its natural state testifies to God's Lordship over winter and the seasons. It gives us hope for the return of spring. This hope is what we ought to give thanks for during these dark days and long nights, and for a reminder of this hope the followers of Boniface introduced the evergreen as christian symbol.   Most Christians don't know this, and they admit ignorance and confusion over the pagan roots of christmas, which to their discredit, they have no intention of uprooting. The fact that the trees have been cut down and cut off from their source of life, and will be mulched or burned in January or thereafter, is quite a propos to the spiritual lesson that goes on year-round in most so-called "bible churches". 

The Churches are as Dead as their Christmas Trees

that decorate their "sanctuaries" during this time of year. They are like wild olive shoots that have been cut off from pagan worship, but have resisted ingrafting to the olive tree of Israel. Consequently they wither and die like the cut off no-longer-evergreens, else they return to their pagan roots a la Roman catholicism or Santa Claus X-mass religion, or else they become neo-platonic gnostic cargo cults a la Lutheranism and Calvinism.

You cannot be in commonwealth with a nation you try to destroy; you cannot renew an eternal covenant while simultaneously abrogating it, you cannot graft branches into a tree that you also uproot. Yet the Nicean churches all teach this incoherence of textual and cultural misappropriation, in open defiance of what they ought to have learned from the apostle Paul writing in Romans 11 and elsewhere. 

By claiming to abrogate and to supercede the law, rather than to fulfill it by doing the commandments, as Jesus taught you in the sermon on the mount, you have refused to partake of the "rich sap of the olive tree".  And are, consequently quite like your "christmas trees", which are very well decorated and put on a good show for a few weeks, even though they are now dead and will soon turn brown.

I endorse rectifying the Germanic Yuletide oak-ash fertility mysticism and its cult of war and human sacrifice, with a tree that points to the heavens and is "ever green". But please don't cut the tree down and put it in your living room, whereafter it will soon ceases to be, denuding the world of yet another witness to God's goodness and sovereignty, his command over the powers of winter cold and snow and his eternal nature and divine will. Let the tree standing in its place, with its own family and friends, and go outside to the grove to meditate, read Psalm 1, and return to the Eternal, blessed be he.

Christmas Trees are now as Idolatrous as Donar's Oak, and Boniface Would Weep

Boniface was a missionary to the pagan Germans. He chopped down the sacred Donar's Oak of Thor or Jupiter, and taught the pagan Germans that the need not fear an endless winter. By considering the evergreen instead, as a sign that winter will end, we can meditate on the goodness of the Eternal God, and of the creation he has made. Boniface if he were alive, would probably weep over the mess that the church has made of a tradition that they started over this event, which undermines the very purpose for which he did it. The purpose of his prophetic act was to exorcise the false fear invoked by an object of pagan worship by destroying it. He defied the so-called gods of "Thor" or "Odin", and faced there wrath and power, but it turns out that they don't in fact exist. When the Germans saw Boniface alive and well, despite his desecration of the idolatrous cult object, and they heard that his words that rang true, and saw that his life was holy and virtuous, they converted and believed.

The Fear of the Eternal is the Beginning of Knowledge

He told them to look to the evergreen, reassure themselves that winter will end. He didn't tell them to chop it down and take it indoors, and turn it into another pagan Romanistic shrine in replacement of the Germanistic one that was destroyed. Or if he did, he shouldn't have. He did, I suppose, involve the Germans in the Roman church and its bogus sacraments, for this he is blameworthy, despite his other merits.

Boniface probably told the Germans that the one true God of heavens and earth has made a cycle of seasons, and that we need not fear an endless winter taught by lying poets, "magicians", and corrupt druids to control and manipulate their people with this ideological control. He probably DID NOT tell them to replace Odin and Thor with "Santa Claus" so that lying and corrupt parents can control and manipulate their children in "being good" with this deceptive ideological control.

Please don't pray to Boniface, or to any other so-called "Saint", or venerate his iconography or attempt to borrow his merit. He can't help now, just learn from his example and rectify the situation. Even if you don't consider him a "saint" in the religious sense, which is why I call him "senor" instead, he has done a good deeed that is worthy of our imitation.

Help Poor Couples Get Married

The historic "Senor" Nicholas was an Asiatic Greek, and a young rich man who helped poor couples get married. Even if you don't consider him a "saint" in the religious sense, which is why I call him "senor" instead, he has done a good deeed that is worthy of our imitation. When you give gifts, don't give "toys". Give with a purpose of helping your child or your friend gain a responsible livelihood and establish a house.

The Sin of Santa: Idolatry, Magic, and Lying to Children

Reconsider the vanity of Santa claus religion of materialist consumerism, and the idolatry of Santa Claus, and stop lying to yourself and to children.

That is part of the reason why I am not a Christian. If my parents and teachers will lie to me about Santa Claus, then why should I believe anything they say about Mary and Joseph and their holy son? If you lie to me about the date of Jesus's birth, why should I believe anything you say about his life, death, and alleged resurrection?

"You shall not insult they deaf; nor lay a stumbling block before the blind." Lev 19:14

Abstain from the Idolatrous Feasts of Roman Saturnalia and Kalenda

The Roman holidays of Saturnalia (and Kalends) were appropriated by the imperial Christianity, and replaced with our advent and christmas. But we could also return to the ancient pre-historic observance, which the Romans had degraded with their polytheistic idolatry.

The Holy Tradition of Adam's Solstice Fast and Feast

Tractate Avodah Zarah 8a ascribes the source of Saturnalia and Kalenda to Adam the first man, who saw that the days were getting shorter and thought it was punishment for his sin:

When the [[Adam|First Man]] saw that the day was continuously shortening, he said, "Woe is me! Because I have sinned, the world darkens around me, and returns to formlessless and void. This is the death to which Heaven has sentenced me!" He decided to spend eight days in fasting and prayer. When he saw the winter solstice, and he saw that the day was continuously lengthening, he said, "It is the order of the world!" He went and feasted for eight days. The following year, he feasted for both. He established them in Heaven's name, but they established them in the name of idolatry.{{Cite web|title=Avodah Zarah 8a:7|url=https://www.sefaria.org/Avodah_Zarah.8a.7|access-date=2021-07-23|website=www.sefaria.org}}

Hannukah: The Law is Light

The feast of dedication, Hannukah, the festival of lights, memorializes the recapture of Jerusalem and dedication of the temple, which coincidentally occured in the last days of Kislev, before the darkest long night of the year, the new moon of Shevat. Therefore Hannukah is a fitting time to remember Adam's Feast, the restoration of the light of Torah and godliness, even during the darkest long night of winter.

"The commandment is a candle, and the law is light." (prov 6:23) 

According to John 10, Joshua (aka Jesus) appears on Solomon's Colonnade in the Temple, walking around but not sitting. Which is why the Judeans asked him "How long will you keep us in suspense? If you are the Christ, tell us plainly!"

To sit in Solomon's colonnade is forbidden except to a king: it is a position of judgement fit only for one who has that authority. It seems that Joshua declined to declare himself Christ and King at this point. Despite the apparent willingness of many to follow him, he decided not to start a political or military revolution.
But Joschka was apparently willing to celebrate Hannukah. He apparently did so in a way that was more-or-less similar to the manner prescribed by the pharisees and sages of the Talmud in what became orthodox Judaism of the diaspora - downplaying the nationalistic and militant significance of the holiday.

I thank God every day for his holy law, because it saves me from this star worship, capitalist consumerism, imposture and deception of the young, contempt for science, and empty mysticism masquerading as novel religious obligation. And so does nearly every Jewish man and woman I know, even the assimilated, agnostic, and buddhist ones regard "christ"mas a prime demonstration of why not to become a christian.   

It seems to me that you are not true "protestants", you are merely heterodox Roman catholics, since you retain the creed, the unbiblical solar calendar, and the bogus communion sacrament - which is anything but - along with the supercessionist ecclesiology and ethics.

What is Sacrament and Holiday?

The Roman church holds "Christmas" to be a "holy obligation". For most protestants churches, it remains fixed communal tradition that has a status equal or similar to that of obligation, for most congregants. This is the sin of "adding to the commands" which Deuteronomy forbids. And it goes in concert with the sin of "removing from the commands" by abrogating the Jewish holidays. (which are not and never were, by the way, obligatory for God-fearing gentiles). This dual movement of erasure and innovation is a perversion of commandment that constitutes a deliberate and politically established state of "lawlessness".

Unlike the biblical Jewish holidays, which are rich in history and natural philosophy, the novel holiday of Christmas is rich in nothing but magic and imposture.

Perhaps the entrainment to ignorance benefits the clergy by keeping the people in habitual failure, therefore inclined to believe the erroneus belief that they are totally depravedand incompetent, and therefore unlikely to resist and improve their moral and material conditions of life, and instead addicted to the periodic fix of empty mysticism offered in the so-called eucharist offering. The habit of ignorance also allows the clergy to get away with apostasy, by ensuring that the biblical sacraments remain ignored, unknown, and stigmatized, and only practiced in the synagogues - who in fact authentically replace the temple worship with communal worship, prayer, and sacramental meals - and are therefore hated for blowing the cover on this fraud.

The "magic of christmas" as the "magic of the eucharist", creates learned helplessness among the institutionalized.    

As everyone knows who bothers to study the source texts, Jesus was not born in midwinter, nor is their any account of celebrating his birthday in the New Testament.  The nativity story is inspiring, but why not do it in midsummer?  And adding novel obligations violates the command, "you shall not add to or remove from this torah", which Jesus reaffirmed in the sermon on the mount. The only holidays he observed are the biblical, Jewish ones, taught in the Torah.

Although Hannukah, is not a biblically commanded observance, it was a popular national holiday that, commemorated an actual historical event.

Examine Yourselves to See if You Be in the Faith!

Why are the so called "bible churches" and "fundamentalists" and "protestants" so eager to assimilate to this Roman religiosity?  Instead of separating from it and "protesting"? why do we adopt Rome and reject Jerusalem?  Perhaps there is something else that you mean to communicate, and we are simply unaware?  

Or perhaps the inescapable conclusion is that either 1) the "Jesus" you proclaim is not the Christ, or 2) He is, but you never knew him nor received the word of his apostles. In the latter case, you are actually gnostics, enemies of the apostles, and false prophets of the antichrist, as are the ecumenical councils collectively. If so, turn and repent.  

Sophistical Refutations

For taking this position, we have been called a "pharisees" by some and "legalist" by others.  Neither predication is true, but these anti-Jewish straw-men are frequently used in christian evangelical polemics so as to avoid responding to the argument on its merits and instead distracting the audience witha red herring and redirecting onto a convenient scapegoat to asserting guilt by association. Therefore please avoid the temptation to waste everyone's time with this response, take the plank out of your own eye first! Examine yourselves and consider your ways, repent, and return to God and to his holy law - to his word!
I don't claim to sit in Moses seat, but I am willing to do as Jesus taught in the sermon on the mount (Matt 5), and go learn from the orthodox Jewish rabbis who do sit in Moses seat, and who transmit the pharisaic tradition.  I've noticed that in evangelical polemics, they are often set up as straw men for you to knock down - but most of you have never even visited a synaogue or had any meaningful theological exchange with the pharisees you scoff at, and most of you are unwilling to go learn, and have no idea what you're talking about. Often you've never even met one, spoken with one. You have not obeyed Jesus anymore than you have obeyed Moses.

Your theologians claim that neither Jesus torah teaching nor Moses's is applicable, those were for the old dispensation which has been superceded by the new dispensation of grace. The "pharisee", like the "Jew" seems to function as an imaginary, hermeneutic figure upon which you can project all your own flaws, rather than a living, flesh and blood representative of "a kingdom of priests, a holy nation" to whom the Apostle Peter wrote his epistle, from whom we ought to learn. Although we, the goyim, the ethnesin, the gentiles have slandered them, we should see their good deads, and give thanks to our father in heaven, as apostle Peter says.

The assumption in Christianity is that Jews don't exist anymore - they have all converted, assimilated, or else been massacred or expelled, and if any still exist, their only remaining task is to convert and disappear as a distinct ethnicity. This is quite murderous, given the history, which you ought to study if you haven't. And the silent agreement in todays churches is complicity.  

In disputes over community life and church politics, I observe that churchmen frequently start accusing each other of acting like pharisees.  But you give yourselves far too much credit.  You all are not pharisees, not even close.   What you are is "hypocrites" - dramatic greeks.  tragicomic thespians.  That's the insult implied in Jesus's rebuke, and you richly deserve it.  Your way is that of Graeco-roman stagecraft, not, apparently, that of discipleship to the Nazarene. Next time you wish to insult one of your own imposters, call him a "hypocrite". Don't flatter him by calling him a pharisee. Jesus was a pharisee from Galilee who had disputes with the Judaean nationalist pharisees. Paul was a pharisee who taught gentiles the noahide covenant. Both were "hasidic" pharisees who emphasized spiritual intent of the commands, without thereby erasing the "letter, (as christians have incorrectly claimed). They were having an internal dispute with the "mitnagdim".  

Come Out of Her, My People, Lest Ye Be Defiled By Her Sins

If you hear, "Turn and repent", as John the baptiser and have Jesus said.  Practice discipleship (talmud), instead of inventing novelties and distracting yourself with vanity as you attempt to outlaw the law itself. As if the word of God can be abrogated by the decree of some "ecumenical" council. It is absurd. As John the revelator saith, "Come out of her my people, lest ye be defiled by her sins."

God Will Not Be Mocked

But if you will not, then you will be called to account someday for every idle word that you utter up on stage, as will I and as will each person when he come before the Almighty and all-knowing judge. God is not mocked; a man will reap what he sows. He who sows to the wind will reap the whirlwind: therefore stop speaking vanities.

We are not going back to "normal".

This will re-occur. 

Sincerely,

Friends of Jared "Scribe" Essig
..................
..................

jaredscribe.com/evergreen-tree

Further Reading